Community vs the Troll

Labrug | 30/03/2009 - 12:02

I was going to post a big essay like thing about Trolls but the topic has been done so much across the net that I would only be repeating much of what has been said and done before. Instead of going into lengthy detail, here are some links.

However, believe it or not, I am here today to say thanks to Trolls, as well as to say an honest thanks all those wonderful people out there who continue to offer their support to Community Theatre in general.

As most if not all of the ITA Regulars, and not so regulars, may be aware, I and a number of other high volume contributors to the site have been regular targets for a number of Trolls, both registered and anon. I do not plan to speak for anyone else as to their personal experiences yet will relay what I have learnt.

The intention of Trolls have been to disrupt and destruct. I and the shows that I have been involved in have frequently attracted the attention of the ranks dissenters, their goal to somehow upset my apparent 'fragile' ego (which as anyone who knows me will tell you is firmly in place and would probably take a thermo-nuclear device to dislodge.) Laughing out loud

The results have been anything but! I have been cast snipes for my directorial work in "Quake" and "Quality Street", and my performances in "Geometry of Love", "The Venetian Twins" and "Romeo and Juliet" have had swings taken at them, as recent examples. I have had posts posing as legitimate anon users, which is actually repeating Trolls, yet the tell-tale-signs are always there. The arguments are without basis or blatantly false. They are personal and usually of no constructive value what-so-ever. Tripe.

Yet in all these instances, there has been one constant that has never failed; the sense of community spirit that erupts from the obvious and not so obvious sectors of the industry. My latest production of "Romeo and Juliet" is a prime example. We had additional audience members turning up based on the posts of a certain registered member (who decided to post anonymously for a change) just to see what the fuss was about. I was offered so many words of support and encouragement as a result of the attacks that I felt immensely proud to be a part of such a wonderful community. The show itself became a focus point for so many people who may have otherwise not paid it any attention.

Best of all, it made audience members seriously consider their own personal opinions of the show they saw, rather than walking away saying "Well that was fun", and it is was always cast in a far better light than that of the Troll. This is true for all the shows I have been a part of. Even though it was not the intent of the Troller, they actually assisted in promoting the show (and inadvertantly myself) to a more positive view. For this, I thank Trolls.

This is why, at the end of the day, it is best to either ignore a Troll or to treat them kindly and with sympathy. After all, as my personal experience has shown me, they are only digging a hole for themselves.

This message was brought to you by a "Hammy and Aging 'Actor'."

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Surely if you hit the stage
Author: Grant Watson (not verified)
Date: 30/03/2009 - 21:47

Surely if you hit the stage where you're posting *about* the trolls, the trolls have won?

Grant
(not a troll)


Not I think
Author: Labrug
Date: 31/03/2009 - 09:22
Labrug's picture

I would PM you on this, if I had a spot to PM you... I disagree.

The Trolls have lost. Their intent being to upset and disrupt through which they have 'power'. The results have been everything but. Their efforts have only strengthened us.

Absit invidia (and DFT No no no)

Jeff Watkins

Home Page
Yahoo Blog Page

SN Profile


Yet here we are discussing
Author: Grant Watson (not verified)
Date: 31/03/2009 - 14:06

Yet here we are discussing trolling and not theatre. : )


Are we...
Author: Labrug
Date: 31/03/2009 - 14:10
Labrug's picture

Are we discussing Trolling or Community Spirit? Trolls were the vehicle. The destination was community. Eye-wink

Erck, nows who's being a Devils Advocate.

Absit invidia (and DFT No no no)

Jeff Watkins

Home Page
Yahoo Blog Page

SN Profile


Jeff, I can state
Author: Robert Whyte
Date: 31/03/2009 - 05:51

Jeff, I can state categorically you are not a ham, in 2006 and 2007, I saw some true hams up on the stage, in some truly tragic and to be totally blunt, awful shows.

I havent seen you in a show yet where I would sling that epithet in your direction.

Basically, all of us are aging, so the comment must have come from a bullet-proof 20 something, who we all know, will NEVER get old!

Regards

Robert


Latest Update
Author: Labrug
Date: 28/10/2010 - 15:35
Labrug's picture

A recent Article on the ABC Web Site...

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2009/11/26/2754284.htm

Starving trolls is key to internet harmonyInternet trolls: people who surf the internet picking fights and abusing people on discussion forums.

By Cassie White

Updated Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:13am AEDT

 

Internet trolls: people who surf the internet picking fights and abusing people on discussion forums. (Benimoto)

Ignoring internet "trolls" is the best way to deter people who surf the internet picking fights and abusing people on discussion forums, says an expert.

ABC News Online this week scrapped its 'Open for Comment' panel in a bid to deter trolls, who constantly start arguments and hurl abuse at other participants.

The move has been criticised by some people, as has ABC policy to moderate comments before posting them to the site.

The role of moderator is to act as a filter to keep debate civil, constructive and on topic. But some feel it is a form of censorship.

"If you start trying to decide what's worthy of being posted then the comments section will be nothing but an extension of the moderator's ego and opinion (as it is now). Vibrant debate and content worth reading will only thrive under a low censorship policy," said ABC commenter, Az.

But others agree with the idea of moderation.

"I find a lack of civility predominates and on occasions it becomes quite abusive ... My concerns are not about an inability to handle 'robust debate' or the 'emotional nature of things'. It is the deliberate attempts to belittle other people," said News Online reader, Annie.

Dr Jason Wilson, lecturer in digital communications at Wollongong University, says many people like to hide behind the mask of anonymity on the internet.

"It allows you to say things you may not say face-to-face or under your own name because you don't have to take responsibility for those comments," he said.

Reformed troll 'Mozart's Ghost' says many people get into trolling for the "thrill" of it.

"You suss out what bothers particular users, get to know them and their weaknesses and play on them," he told ABC News Online.

"You try and engage them in some sort of debate based on logic when you don't really care. You'll say anything just to get them to waste their time talking to you."

He says more seasoned trolls generally learn how to cleverly word their abuse in order to slip past moderators.

"You've got to be a lot smarter than that - that's level one of trolling," he said.

"You've got to get to level five where you're more subtle and subversive where people don't actually know if you're serious or not. It really mucks with people's minds."

Dr Wilson says crying censorship is a common complaint from trolls.

"There's a number of tried and true tactics that you'll find trolls using - saying something that's completely unacceptable and then immediately resorting to that complaint that they're being censored," he said.

Ironically, Mozart's Ghost is now "on the forces of good" and runs an internet forum.

 

Don't feed the trolls

 

He says the best way to make a troll go away is to simply ignore them.

"You can hardly go back into a thread and post if the last post is yours," he said.

"If you just ignore us, it's probably a good tactic because we do want some material we can come back at you with."

Dr Wilson agrees that the best way to take a troll down is to not react.

"People who run blogs and moderate comments need to be firm and not let any of this stuff through," he said.

"The good old motto is 'don't feed the troll'. Don't acknowledge them, don't give them attention, don't react because that's what they want."

He says in his experience, serial trolls tend to be men up to the age of about 30 and sometimes they can take things too far.

"[I've heard about] threats of violence, various kinds of low-level stalking," he said.

"It's something that does happen and people really do go after each other when they're having blog wars and what have you.

"But that happens in the mainstream media as well - people get vilified and attacked by mainstream journos as well, so it's all swings and roundabouts really."

First posted Thu Nov 26, 2009 12:43pm AEDT

Absit invidia (and DFT No no no)

Jeff Watkins

Looking for an Agent? Read this first!!


 28/10/2010 - 23:19 jeckers This strikes me as the talk
Informing
Author: Labrug
Date: 29/10/2010 - 09:30
Labrug's picture

Because you are new to the forum, I will forgive you. You are exactly right in that Trolls are to be ignored and as I am a regular target for Trolls, being one of the regulars and an admin officer for the site, I have learnt that this is the best way to deal with them.

However, other people, especially newer people to the net and it's pitfalls, are not aware. Thus I post to inform others. That is basic journalism I would guess, but I am not professional and therefore do not get paid for my 'work'. Mine is a community service.

As for the "community vs Trolls' aspect, again, this was a process of informing, and in a slight way, of thanking people whom have supported others in a positive manner, and to highlight that sometimes Trolls are their own worst enemies. Further reason to leave them alone.

You are entitled to your opinion and I do not begrudge you that. My opinion is that I feel the purpose of the post was misunderstood, and that is an easy thing to do.

Absit invidia (and DFT No no no)

Jeff Watkins

Looking for an Agent? Read this first!!


Fair enough mate.I think
Author: jeckers
Date: 29/10/2010 - 12:20

Fair enough Jeff.

I think anyone on this site, even new people such as I can see the good work you are doing, and that you are doing it for free to keep the community together is absolutely great mate.

I think the point I wanted to make and didn't do a crash-hot job, is that people see your good work and you don't necessarily have to stroke them in such a manner. Just my opinion though mate.

Community versus trolls. Community a win!

Best,
J Grant.


Gold! Getting paid? Cassie
Author: jeffhansen
Date: 29/10/2010 - 07:10
jeffhansen's picture

Gold!
Getting paid?
Smiling
Cassie White, the journalist who wrote the above piece is the only one getting paid....

www.meltheco.org.au


User login

Who's online
There are currently 0 users and 249 guests online.

Navigation

Syndicate
XML feed

Featured event